How to Determine the Right Success Metrics for Learning and Development Initiatives

Download the full version of this guide here: Download Success Metrics Guide →

Introduction

Learning and Development is no longer optional. In today’s workplace, where skills are the new currency, L&D sits at the center of how organizations retain talent, innovate, and stay competitive. But demonstrating the impact of L&D requires more than reporting course completions or satisfaction surveys.

The LinkedIn Workplace Learning Report 2024 highlights the urgency of this challenge. Aligning learning programs to business goals remains the top priority for L&D leaders for the second year in a row (LinkedIn, 2024). Yet fewer than 40% of organizations surveyed say their L&D initiatives are actually aligned with business objectives.

The message is clear: leaders believe in L&D, but they want proof. This guide lays out a step by step approach to defining the right success metrics, covering training, digital skills programs, and coaching

Step 1: Anchor Metrics to Organizational Goals

Metrics must begin with business strategy. Without a direct link to organizational priorities, measurement risks being overlooked.

Stakeholder questions to ask

1. To executives: What are our top three business goals this year. Which of these depend most on workforce capability.
   
2. To business unit leaders: Where are performance gaps holding you back? If developing your people could fix one issue, what would you choose?
   

Example
If retention is a top priority, success metrics might include voluntary turnover among trained compared with untrained groups, engagement survey results, and retention of high performers. For coaching initiatives, this can extend to retention of leaders who receive coaching compared with those who do not.

Step 2: Clarify Learning Objectives

Once goals are clear, define what the program is meant to achieve for learners or coachees.

Stakeholder questions to ask

1. To L&D designers: Which specific skills, behaviors, or mindsets should participants develop. How will we measure mastery?
   
2. To line managers: What observable changes would you expect in your team after this training or coaching?
   

Example
A sales program focused on objection handling might track test scores, cross sell attempts, and average deal size. For a coaching program, objectives could include increasing leadership confidence, improving decision making, or preparing leaders for stretch roles.

Step 3: Balance Leading and Lagging Metrics

Leading metrics provide early signals such as participation or engagement. Lagging metrics capture long term results such as productivity, retention, or revenue. Both are necessary.

Stakeholder questions to ask

1. To HR analytics: Which measures can we track in real time, and which will take months to show impact?
   
2. To executives: Do you want early indicators of progress, or only hard business outcomes?
   

Example
LinkedIn reports that learners who set career goals engage with learning four times more. That is a strong leading metric. For coaching, leading measures might include program enrollment, number of coaching sessions completed, or coachee satisfaction. Lagging indicators could include promotion rates of coached leaders, engagement scores in their teams, or higher retention of high potential employees.

Step 4: Apply Frameworks like Kirkpatrick Thoughtfully

The Kirkpatrick model is valuable if you apply all four levels. The levels are: Reaction, Learning, Behavior, and Results.

Stakeholder questions to ask

1. To learners or coachees: Was the training or coaching relevant and engaging. What new skills or perspectives have you gained?
   
2. To managers: Have you observed employees applying new skills or behaviors? Can you share examples?
   
3. To executives: Which business outcomes should we connect this initiative to?
   

Example
In cybersecurity training, employees might rate the course highly for relevance, score better on phishing tests, click fewer phishing emails in simulations, and cause fewer actual breaches. In coaching, coachees might describe sessions as highly relevant, report greater self awareness and leadership growth, demonstrate more effective delegation, and strengthen succession pipelines.

Step 5: Tailor Metrics to Stakeholders

Executives, managers, and learners value different outcomes. Success metrics should reflect those perspectives.

Stakeholder questions to ask

1. To executives: Which KPIs would convince you L&D is delivering value.
   
2. To managers: What changes in your team would prove that training or coaching worked.
   
3. To learners or coachees: What outcomes would make this program worthwhile for your career.
   

Example
LinkedIn reports that helping employees develop careers is now the fourth most important L&D priority. That makes metrics such as internal mobility, promotions, or career plan adoption especially relevant.

Step 6: Leverage Technology and Data Integration

Measurement depends on reliable data. This often means integrating learning systems with HRIS, performance management, and even sales or customer data.

Stakeholder questions to ask

1. To IT and data teams: Which systems can we connect to track performance impact. How do we ensure data accuracy and privacy.
   
2. To L&D operations: What metrics can be captured automatically, and what requires input from managers or employees.
   

Example
For compliance training, LMS completions and quiz scores are important, but the real outcome is fewer breaches, which are tracked in compliance systems. For coaching, HR data might show whether coached leaders are promoted faster, retain their teams longer, or deliver higher performance ratings.

Step 7: Balance Quantitative and Qualitative Evidence

Numbers are essential, but stories and context bring them to life.

Stakeholder questions to ask

1. To learners or coachees: Can you describe a time you applied what you learned or a coaching insight in your role.
   
2. To managers: What changes in behavior, confidence, or collaboration have you seen.
   
3. To executives: Would real life stories of employee impact help you trust the metrics.
   

Example
After a digital skills program, data may show that most employees improved proficiency, while feedback reveals greater confidence experimenting with AI tools. After coaching, participants may share stories of handling conflict better, making more strategic decisions, or leading with greater empathy.

Step 8: Build a Success Metrics Framework

All of this should be pulled together in a framework that connects goals, learning objectives, metrics, and business outcomes.

Stakeholder questions to ask

1. To executives: Does this framework provide the visibility you need into impact.
   
2. To HR partners: Are these metrics aligned with other talent measures.
   
3. To L&D: Do we have the capacity to track and report these consistently.
   

Example
For a retention initiative, the goal might be reducing attrition. The learning objective could be strengthening manager coaching skills. Learning metrics might include completions and practice assessments. Behavioral metrics might include frequency and quality of feedback sessions. Business outcomes would be lower turnover and higher engagement scores in those managers’ teams.

Download the full version of this guide here: Performance Goal Tracker Template download

For practical examples, questions to ask and common mistakes to avoid, download the full guide.

Download the full version of this guide here: Download Success Metrics Guide →